Irish whiskey history is a story of tradition, rootedness, and not a little bit of stubbornness, and Midleton Irish Whiskey is a great example.
History and tradition ground me
A few years ago I took one of those genetic DNA tests, and unlike so many people I know, there was very little ethnic diversity in my gene pool. What those results meant to me was that, despite my not being able to trace back my family tree beyond a couple of generations, my ancestors were pretty well rooted in location for almost 500 years. For good or for ill, they weathered the storms of circumstance surrounding them and continued with their traditions, come what may. That thought gave me a feeling of rootedness, and maybe not a little bit of stubborn pride as well. The history of Irish whiskey follows that concept to a tee, and Midleton Irish Whiskey is a great example.
When I went to look into Midleton Irish Whiskey, Irish whiskey history featured prominently. History nerd that I am, I started soaking up the story of the rise, and fall, and rise again of the Irish whiskey industry. I won’t go into all the detail here (thank goodness for that!)…there’s a wonderful YouTube video that succinctly and sufficiently tells that story. However, there are two items I want to highlight though…firstly, in the late 18th century the Irish whiskey distillers started using unmalted barley in their mash to avoid paying the English a tax on malted barley, thus creating the unique taste of Irish Pot Still Whiskey we still have today (stubbornness pays off!). Secondly, the Irish whiskey distillers doggedly clung onto the tradition of using Single Pot Stills to make their whiskey, even after the invention (by an Irishman, no less) of the Coffey (or Continuous) Still in the early half of the 19th century. That desire to maintain their traditions cost the Irish whiskey industry dearly, and it took more than a century to make up for it. In the end though, this combination of stubbornness and rootedness in tradition gave us the wonderful world of Irish whiskey.
[Side Note: I had previously reviewed some of these expressions in Can I buy a vowel?...I find it interesting to compare how my palate has changed (or at least my adjectives have improved) since then. I’ve included those older reviews in the Notes section of the current review just for grins and giggles.]
To the lineup, then!
Midleton Irish Whiskey tasting
At Gordon’s DTX, March 14, 2018
- Nose: butterscotch, malted milk, cereal, lightly citrus, apricot
- Taste: soft, oily, coats mouth, cinnamon, nutmeg, cream
- Finish: crème brulée, soft cinnamon, lemon pudding
- Comments: very straightforward and soft, a lightness at the end
- Nose: very lightly sweet, not much aroma, floral
- Taste: very smooth entrance, lightly oily but light body, sweet and spicy
- Finish: warm spices at the very end
- Comments: approachable and drinkable, very nice
Redbreast 12yr Cask Strength
- Nose: caramel, vanilla, grapefruit, grass, corn (bourbon-like)
- Taste: thick, cinnamon, cardamom
- Finish: burnt sugar and warm spices
- Comments: bourbon-like, I like this
- Nose: heavy spice immediately, cinnamon, high alcoholic with water pineapple
- Taste: alcohol immediately, hard to tease out; with water, still high spice, peppers
- Finish: pepper grows strongly with alcohol
- Comments: Still harsh, not my favorite
- Nose: clover honey, lemony,
- Taste: thick body, parsley, brown sugar, apples,
- Finish: sharp, ginger, apples, bitter lemon
- Comments: different nose from the taste, the bitterness is hard to nail down
Green Spot Single Pot Still Irish Whiskey
- Nose: grass, hay, light grain, pineapple
- Taste: fruity, sharp entry, pears, light body
- Finish: the sharpness continues, juicy, fruity, grassy bitterness
- Comments: a bright easy to drink whiskey
- Nose: apples, honey
- Taste: starts smooth, very sweet, full body
- Finish: cotton candy
- Comments: Higher unmarked barley, almost too sweet, not something I would buy
Green Spot Chateau Montelena Cask
- Nose: large cooked fruit richness, underneath green apples and cut grassy, light butter, almond extract
- Taste: Thick, oily, sharp, light vanilla, buttercream frosting, tannic
- Finish: pepper rises, buttercream
- Comments: very rich in nose, thick in body, lots of layers, really wonderful
Midleton Dair Ghaelach
- Nose: Chinese foods like 5-spice, soy sauce, almost meaty, caramel underneath
- Taste: strong baking spices, gets richer, cooked plums, chocolate cake
- Finish: cooked fruit at the end
- Comments: surprising and delicious after the nose, the best of the lot
Time for new roots?
As I write this post, we’ve just today finished selling our California house of over 20 years. Part of me is sad that those roots have been cut…that was, after all, where we raised our two wonderful daughters, and it’s a huge part of their history as well as mine. Part of me longs for that feeling of rootedness, of permanence, that living in a place for a long time provides. However, Boston offers its own brand of rootedness…this city is the cradle of America after all, and everywhere I turn there is history, a sense of place (that’s what first captivated me about living here). Maybe I’m being replanted, and maybe it’s time to set down roots here…hey, I’m stubborn enough to do just that.
Slainté! L’chaim! Cheers!