Nikka Japanese Whisky & Old Potrero Rye Whiskey

Jump to Reviews

From two sides of the Pacific ocean comes two distinct rye whiskies in two different styles, Nikka Japanese whisky and Old Potrero Rye whiskey.

Collage of Nikka Japanese whisky & Old Potrero Rye whiskey bottle labels.

Whisky has become big business in Japan, and there are many great choices from which to choose.

I had the good fortune to attend a Whisky Wednesday at Gordon’s DTX that not only featured Nikka Japanese whisky, but also offered a tasting of Old Potrero Rye Whiskey from Anchor Distilling & Importing in San Francisco.

It was an interesting pairing, delicate malts then strong ryes, but it was worth it.

Kelly McCarthy, the brand ambassador from Anchor Distilling, gave us what amounted to a Master class on each of these expressions, and I soaked it up.

(Really…you really went there, huh!)

Jump To: hide

Japanese whisky history

Nikka Japanese Whisky & Old Potrero Rye Whiskey

Nikka Pure Malt

Nikka Coffey Malt

Nikka Coffey Grain

Old Potrero 18th Century Rye

Old Potrero Straight Rye Whiskey

Final thoughts

Related Tasting Notes

Japanese whisky history

Kelly started by giving us a little history of whisky brewing in Japan, then a quickie lesson into the Coffey-type still used at Nikka. I’ll summarize, but if you just want to skip ahead to the tasting notes, I’ll meet up with you there.

Subscribe to Scotch & Scones!

Sign up for my weekly featured recipe and you'll get two recipes, Extra-Tangy Sourdough Bread and Mint Chocolate Chunk Scones!

In 1918, Masataka Taketsuru went to Scotland to study about making Scotch whisky. He came back to Japan to eventually become the first Japanese Master Distiller and founder of the Yoichi and Miyagikyo distilleries, both of which are under the Nikka brand.

The Coffey (continuous column) stills used at Miyagikyo remove some of the impurities that a pot still would leave behind, thus giving the product an oily, sweeter texture and delicate flavor.

In contrast, a pot still would make a more hearty, earthy whisky. Fun fact: it’s the Coffey still that makes vodka such a neutral alcohol.

Kelly McCarthy behind Nikka Japanese whisky & Old Potrero Rye whiskey bottles on a counter. — Kelly McCarthy led our tasting of Old Potrero Rye and Nikka whisky

Are you back with me? Eyes haven’t glazed over too much? Good…onto the tasting then!

[Side Note: the italicized notes below are from Anchor Distilling’s Portfolio Guide]

Nikka Japanese Whisky & Old Potrero Rye Whiskey

At Gordon’s DTX, presented by Kelly McCarthy, December 6, 2017

Nikka Pure Malt

43% ABV

Taketsuru Pure Malt whisky is the perfect marriage of Yoichi & Miyagikyo. Its gentle malt flavor, fruitiness and extremely well-balanced taste make it a perfect entry point into the world of Nikka. Sherry butts, bourbon barrels, new American oak and re-charred casks were chosen for this expression.

Type: Japanese

Tasting Notes

Nose: red fruit, clover honey, hay, peaches, white chocolate
Taste: light body, slightly oily, caramel and floral, slightly beachy and smoky
Finish: the white pepper lays on the sides of the tongue, the slight medicinal note lingers
Comments: lots of flavor layers because it’s a malted blend. The Yoichi side of the blend brings the beachy flavor (it sits on the water), while the Miyagikyo brings that Highland-like delicate flavor (as it’s up in the foothills of Japan). I like this one the best of the 3 Nikkas presented

Nikka Coffey Malt

45%ABV

The Nikka Coffey Malt is the result of a unique distillation process using Nikka's Coffey stills, which are normally used for grain whisky production. This rare 100% malt bottling offers a surprisingly rich texture

Type: Japanese

Tasting Notes

Nose: more pronounced caramel & grain aroma, tropical fruit (mango, banana)
Taste: fudgy and sweet, med-light body, a bit of pine
Finish: the evergreen notes fade slowly
Comments: a more intense version of the Pure Malt, good layered complexity

Nikka Coffey Grain

45%ABV

Nikka Whisky Coffey Grain is a grain whisky, which is typically used for blending but rarely bottled on its own. The secret behind Nikka’s grain whisky is the unique flavor generated by Coffey stills, which are traditional continuous stills patented by Aeneas Coffey in the 1830s. The rich corn and touch of honeyed citrus taste of Coffey Grain is also excellent in cocktails.

Type: Japanese

Tasting Notes

Nose: very tropical immediately, a little bit of coffee in the background, light brown sugar
Taste: light body, corn sweetness, delicate flavor with no hint of spice
Finish: the corn sweetness lasts and lasts
Comments: a little too sweet, almost cloying (it’s 95% corn & 5% malted barley)

Old Potrero 18th Century Rye

51.2% ABV

Handmade oak barrels, lightly toasted in the traditional manner, impart a wonderfully subtle flavor. In the 18th century, barrels were made by heating the staves over a re of oak chips, allowing them to be bent and formed into a barrel shape. During this process, the inside of the barrel would become toasted, but not charred. For aging, several uncharred oak barrels, both new and used, to achieve the balanced complexity that complements this whiskey’s traditional heritage.

Type: American

Tasting Notes

Nose: nutty, smoky, clove spice
Taste: rye immediately then gingerbread afterwards, light body, some smokiness
Finish: fades to a soft pine (almost juniper and brown sugar
Comments: it hits you in the face...like eating a caraway seed (unless that’s because I just tasted it after the Japanese whisky), malted rye; It's really good!

Old Potrero Straight Rye Whiskey

48.5%ABV

This straight rye whiskey was aged in new handmade charred oak barrels. In traditional barrel making, the cooper heats the staves over a re of oak chips, allowing them to be bent and formed into a barrel. During this process, the inside of the barrel becomes lightly toasted. By the early 19th century, coopers had learned that if they allowed the heat to continue, the inside of the barrel would burst into flames and become charred. Handmade oak barrels—charred in this traditional manner—impart a rich color and unique character to this rye whiskey.

Type: American

Tasting Notes

Nose: softer nose, lightly rye, honey
Taste: soft rye entry, pepper rises halfway then falls
Finish: the cloves rise at the end, a light sweet hazelnut at the end
Comments: it’s an approachable rye, not intimidating at all

Nikka Japanese whisky & Old Potrero Rye whiskey lineup on a counter. — Nikka Japanese whisky & Old Potrero Rye whiskey lineup (photo credit: Gordon's DTX)

Final thoughts

Both these brands are good representations of their respective styles, and I would recommend them highly.

Take a leap from San Francisco to Japan across that little pond called the Pacific Ocean. You’ll be glad you did!

Slainté! L’chaim! Cheers!

Tammy

Whiskey comes in many different styles. There's bourbon, rye whiskey, blended whiskey, and peated whiskey. Here's where you can find a rye whiskey I've reviewed in a lineup.